Handmade wooden ornaments, cream knitted mittens and a small evergreen wreath on a linen-covered holiday craft table in warm window light.

Sherman's Holiday Craft Fair Season Starts Sunday at the Athletic Club

In 2008, Sharon Miller started a holiday craft show in Sherman. She was a retired elementary school teacher from the Williamsville School District. Her friend Marj Schwager volunteered to organize it from the second show on, and the State Journal-Register reported in 2015 that booth-rental money went to a scholarship in Miller's name through the Illinois Education Association.

This Sunday, November 22, the 18th Annual Sherman Holiday Wonderland opens at the Sherman Athletic Club, 300 S. 1st St. It runs 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. with 28 vendor and craft booths, and admission is free. The show that kicks off Sherman's holiday shopping started with a teacher and a friend who kept it going. The other dates on this year's calendar also come from volunteer groups, nonprofit halls and charity causes. Here is how the season runs from Sunday to mid-December.

Sherman's Holiday Shopping Calendar

  1. Sunday, November 22: 18th Annual Sherman Holiday Wonderland, Sherman Athletic Club, 10 a.m. to 4 p.m., free admission.
  2. Saturday, November 28: 5th Annual Handmade Village Christmas, listed on the Village of Sherman calendar.
  3. Saturday, December 12, morning: St. John Vianney Catholic Church's 26th Annual Cookie Walk, Raffle and Gift Gala, 8:30 to 11 a.m.
  4. Saturday, December 12, late afternoon: Sherman Church of the Nazarene's Home for the Holidays, 4 to 6 p.m.

Thanksgiving is Thursday, November 26, so the first two dates fall on either side of the holiday: the Sunday before and the Saturday after. That Saturday is also the day after Black Friday. Two Saturday events in December close out the season.

Why the Wonderland Went Handmade

The Holiday Wonderland has changed over the years. In the 2015 State Journal-Register story, Schwager explained how the vendor mix changed:

"We've had company vendors in the past, but we've gotten more and more requests for handmade things, so we've been doing that instead."

That year's tables had scarves and towels, bags of peanut brittle, knickknacks and wreaths made of burlap. Schwager told the paper that shoppers were buying Christmas presents and also a lot of baby gifts, things she called personal, "not something that everybody has."

The 2026 listing describes a day of shopping for gifts and holiday decorations across 28 vendor and craft booths. Last year, the Williamsville village newsletter told shoppers to follow the Sherman Holiday Wonderland Facebook page for updates and a vendor list as the 2025 show got closer. That show was the 17th, held Sunday, November 23, 2025, with the same 10-to-4 hours. The Facebook page is still the best place to see who is selling before you go.

The scholarship has continued too. In January 2024, the Illinois Education Association announced that the Abe Lincoln Chapter of IEA-Retired was sponsoring the Sharon Miller Memorial Scholarship, a $1,000 award for students majoring in education. A craft show that began with a Williamsville teacher is still linked to an award for future teachers.

The Hall on South 1st Street

Both the Wonderland and last year's Handmade Village Christmas were held in the same building, and that building has its own volunteer story. The Sherman Athletic Club has been part of Sherman since 1946. It is a nonprofit supported by its members, volunteers and the community. The club says it has supported youth sports, hosted community events and fundraisers, and been a gathering place for weddings, birthday parties, reunions and celebrations. The venue holds 240 people.

A volunteer board runs the club: a president, vice president, secretary, treasurer and four more members. Membership starts with an application, which the board votes on at its next monthly meeting. Meetings are on the third Wednesday of each month at 6:30 p.m., and the club says visitors are always welcome to stop by. Approved members get a tour and their own key.

If you have only been inside for a craft show, it helps to know who runs the place. The club has been a community gathering spot for eight decades, and on these weekends the people filling it are holiday shoppers.

The Saturday After Thanksgiving

The Village of Sherman lists the 5th Annual Handmade Village Christmas for Saturday, November 28, 2026, and posted a notice about it on October 24. At five years old, it is much newer than the Wonderland, and its name puts the focus on handmade goods, the same direction the older show took.

Last year's edition, A Handmade Village Christmas, ran Saturday, November 29, 2025, from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. at the Sherman Athletic Club. That made for a long day, and the early start beat most retail openings that weekend. For this year's hours and location, check the Village event page as the date gets close.

With the Wonderland and the Handmade Village Christmas six days apart, a household can shop local makers on the Sunday before Thanksgiving and again on the Saturday after. If the Sunday show sells out of what you wanted, you get a second chance before December.

December 12 Splits Into Morning and Afternoon

The season ends with two free events on the same Saturday at different times, so you can go to both.

Cookie Walk, Raffle and Gift Gala Home for the Holidays
Host St. John Vianney Catholic Church Sherman Church of the Nazarene
Time 8:30 to 11 a.m. 4 to 6 p.m.
Location Activity Center, 902 St. John Drive 7085 Village Center Road
Santa Selfies with Santa, 8:30 to 10:30 a.m. Pictures with Santa
Admission Free Free

The morning event is the 26th Cookie Walk, Raffle and Gift Gala. It has homemade cookies, candies and breads, gifts from local vendors, raffles and complimentary refreshments. Santa photos are by free-will donation, and the money goes to Holy Family Food Pantry. The Diocese of Springfield event listing links to a Facebook event page for more details. Santa photos end at 10:30, half an hour before the gala closes, so families who want a photo should come early.

In the late afternoon, Home for the Holidays has live music, games, arts and crafts, pictures with Santa, and several $100 gift-card giveaways, all with free admission. There are five hours between the end of the gala and the start of Home for the Holidays, so a Sherman family can pick up cookies in the morning, take the afternoon off, and finish the day with music and crafts.

Across three dates, a donated Santa photo helps stock a food pantry, a craft show that began with a Williamsville teacher is still linked to a scholarship in her name, and a volunteer-run club founded in 1946 hosts much of the season. For the rest of what Sherman offers through the year, see our Sherman neighborhood guide or last summer's look at the amphitheater, kitchens and trail close to home.

The team at Melissa's Listings has worked in Sherman and the rest of Central Illinois since 1994. If you're starting to think about your next move while you shop the Wonderland, start with an instant home valuation and see what your Sherman home is worth this season.

Work With Us

Follow Me on Instagram